[Stoves] Action about Stove Testing

[Robert Penn Taylor]

Of the two UCB water boiling tests that can accessed from the 
bioenergylists website, which one are people looking into?

This one:
http://ceihd.berkeley.edu/Docs/WBT_data-calculation_sheet_3.0.xls
which can be found by clicking on the link that says "Stove Performance 
and Evaluation Protocols, Forms, and Guidelines, David Pennise, Rob 
Bailis, CEIHD March 2006" at http://www.bioenergylists.org/en/performance

OR

This one:
http://ehs.sph.berkeley.edu/hem/hem/protocols/WBT_data-calculation_sheet.xls
which can be found by clicking on the link that says "Water Boiling Test 
(WBT), Kirk Smith, Household Environment and Health (HEH) Project 
standard protocol for indoor air pollution measurements and stove 
performance tests (SPTs), December 2004" at 
http://www.bioenergylists.org/en/performance


They appear to be similar, but are not identical. Which one contains the 
contested calculations?

-Penn Taylor